Are protein requirements increased by physical activity? This
seemingly simple question has been hotly debated for years and
remains one of the most controversial issues in sports nutrition.
Unless you are regularly participating in strenuous strength, speed
or endurance exercise for more than an hour each day, then your
protein needs are no greater than those recommended for a healthy,
balanced diet.
4(i). Protein and Amino Acids
Protein is essential for life and is a major part of the body. It
is found primarily in muscle. We need protein for the growth and
repair of tissues. During digestion, proteins are broken down into
smaller units called amino acids. There are 20 different amino
acids, which can be combined to make many different proteins. Our
bodies can make proteins from amino acids, but we are unable to
produce nine of the amino acids - the essential amino acids - so
these need to be supplied by the diet. Only some foods - the
complete protein foods - contain all the essential amino acids,
shown in Table 1.
|
Table 1. Complete Protein Foods |
|
Milk and dairy products
|
|
Eggs
|
|
Fish
|
|
Meat and poultry
|
|
Corn plus peas or beans
|
|
Rice plus beans
|
|
Lentils plus bread
|
Only animal sources contain all the essential amino acids, but
by combining different plant proteins you can also make complete
protein foods. Therefore, strict vegetarians need to plan their
diet carefully to ensure that their combination of plant foods
provides them with all the essential amino acids. Protein quality
is improved when dairy products are added to a plant food and when
plant-based foods, such as wheat and beans, are mixed together.
Good matches are muesli and milk, rice pudding, sesame seed bread,
pitta bread and houmous, baked beans on toast or lentil curry and
rice.
4(ii). Protein Needs
The average daily protein requirements - expressed in grams per
day for every kilogram you weigh (g/kg/d) - is summarised in Table
2.
For people who are sedentary or have low levels of activity, the
daily protein requirement is equivalent to 0.75g per kg of body
weight. So a person weighing 60kg would need 45g (60 x 0.75) of
protein per day.
If you are exercising more than an hour each day, then your
daily requirement is slightly increased to 1.0-1.2g of protein per
kg of body weight - that's 60-72g of protein if you weigh 60kg.
However, this requirement is still well within the amount that is
typically consumed, on average, in the UK and therefore protein
supplements are not necessary.
Experts recommend a further increase for athletes in the order
of 1.2-1.4g/kg/d for endurance athletes and 1.6-1.7g/kg/d for
strength athletes. When protein requirements are increased, for
example, during heavy endurance training, the amount can simply be
achieved by increasing the overall energy intake of the diet
without altering the proportion of protein consumed. Therefore, no
adjustment is necessary to the foods or the composition of the
normal diet.
Experts also state that there is no advantage - both in terms of
performance or muscle size - to taking more than 2g of protein per
kg of body weight per day providing carbohydrate needs are met.
Commonly, athletes report excess intakes of 100g of protein per
day. If this was all used for muscle protein synthesis, muscle mass
would increase by about 500g/d. But, in reality, the extra protein
is metabolised and excreted, rather than converted into muscle.
|
Table 2. Daily Protein Requirements
|
| |
|
Activity level |
Protein
g/kg/d |
|
Sedentary to low levels of activity
|
0.75 |
|
Regular activity > 1 hour per day
|
1.0 - 1.2 |
|
Endurance athletes
|
1.2 - 1.4 |
|
Strength athletes
|
1.6 - 1.7 |
In practice, providing you are eating enough food to meet your
energy and carbohydrate requirements, achieving an adequate amount
of protein is fairly easy. Table 3 lists the protein content of
some common foods. Animal sources are richer in protein than
vegetable sources and, therefore, a larger quantity of non-animal
sources need to be consumed to provide the equivalent amounts of
protein. This can be particularly problematic for vegetarian
strength and endurance athletes due to the bulk of the fibre-rich
vegetables that they need to eat to meet daily protein needs. In
this situation a protein supplement may be advisable.
|
Table 3. Protein Content of Everyday Foods
|
| |
|
Portion of food |
Protein (g) |
|
150g lean meat or poultry
|
40 |
|
150g fish
|
33 |
|
150g soya beans
|
21 |
|
150g tofu, lentils, kidney beans
|
12 |
|
135g baked beans
|
10 |
|
284ml milk
|
10 |
|
30g cheddar cheese
|
8 |
|
30g cheddar cheese
|
8 |
|
1 egg
|
7 |
|
2 slices of bread
|
6 |
4(iii). Protein and Amino Acid Supplements
It is easy to meet your protein needs from food. High-protein
diets have been falsely associated with exercise training, due to
the mistaken belief that this will lead to greater muscle mass and
strength, simply because muscle itself is protein. But, despite the
influential power of advertising, all a protein supplement will do
is burn a large hole in your pocket! Nor is there a benefit in
taking expensive amino acid supplements. It doesn't matter if
excess protein is obtained from food or a supplement it still won't
be turned into muscle!
During exercise, the body relies mainly on muscle glycogen,
liver glycogen and fat stores for fuel. Protein is used as muscle
fuel if glycogen stores are low. It is important to ensure that
glycogen stores are kept well topped up to stop muscle protein
being used as fuel. The best way to achieve this is to eat
additional carbohydrate before, during and after exercise - see
section on carbohydrates.